Sight-Singing Books Review
(1) Music for Sight Singing (9th Edition),Edition by Nancy Rogers & Robert W. Ottman, Published by Pearson, 2013.
- Are the materials specific to one method of teaching?
Yes, the materials of this book are structured from a wide range of folk musics from the world and practice exercises, which focus on developing sight singing skills and ear.
- Are the materials graded for difficulty?
Yes, the materials of this book arranges from simple level to more complicated contents from the beginning chapters to the end.
- Is the material scaffolded appropriately?
Yes, the material is very cohesive to the knowledge that each unit introduces and the arrangement of the material is very concise for reading.
- What are the strengths and weaknesses of this materials?
The strengths of materials are the accessibility for public school for daily based music training and the book is not too long and complex for reviewing; the weaknesses can be the lack of songs collection especially for professional voice training.
- Are the materials based in real music or specially composed exercises?
Yes, I think the materials includes both melodies from real music especially folk songs and composed exercises based on different difficulties level and knowledge of the unit.
- Do the materials feature a variety of rhythmic and melodic content?
Yes, every unit in this book combines both rhythmic and melodic based exercises. Rhythmic exercises include simple and compound meters to irregular or changing meter signatures; melodic exercises include all minor and major keys in any diatonic modes and various harmonic progressions.
(2) Melodia:a comprehensive course in sight-singing, by Samuel Winkley Cole.
- Are the materials specific to one method of teaching?
No, the book focuses on teaching both large group classes and individual reading and sing-alone based on the requirement from instructors.
- Are the materials graded for difficulty?
Yes, the content of this book includes level of difficulty from diatonic to harmonic exercises, one part to two part, keys from less to more signatures, major to minor and easy to hard in rhythmic patterns.
- Is the material scaffolded appropriately?
Yes, the material are structured into eleven different series and there is an introduction of knowledge for exercises on the beginning of each unit.
- What are the strengths and weaknesses of this materials?
The strengths of this book are abundant exercises for both public and private teaching use, clear clarification and goals for each unit, all exercises are related to official authorship. The weaknesses can be the edition is old and lack of modern and cultural diverse materials.
- Are the materials based in real music or specially composed exercises?
Yes, the source of the materials are mostly from 17th to 19th century famous western music composers and masters of choral compositions.
- Do the materials feature a variety of rhythmic and melodic content?
Yes, well classified by key-signature and time-signature into many different series.
(3)Ear-training and Sight-singing Applied to Elementary Musical Theory:A Practical and Coördinated Course for Schools and Private Study, by George Anson Wedge.
- Are the materials specific to one method of teaching?
Yes, the purpose of this book is to show how to teach elements of music by using the three particular ways: exercises to be written, exercises for diction to be used for ear-training and exercise for sight-reading.
- Are the materials graded for difficulty?
No, the book has no specific clarification of level.
- Is the material scaffolded appropriately?
Not exactly, the material structures from a random setting of knowledge for teacher to use.
- What are the strengths and weaknesses of this materials?
The book has very specific explanation and introduction of each basic music element and definition that can be feasible in public school and private instruction. However, the arrangement of this material is too random and complex for beginning music learner. Moreover, lack of songs collection from real musics.
- Are the materials based in real music or specially composed exercises?
No, most of the songs are composed by authors instead of officials.
- Do the materials feature a variety of rhythmic and melodic content?
Yes.
(4)The practice of sight-singing, by John Henry Cornell
- Are the materials specific to one method of teaching?
Yes, the book introduces the method of measuring sight-singing skill is based on a thorough knowledge, theoretical and practical from tonality to rhythm.
- Are the materials graded for difficulty?
In some ways from exercises but not very clear from the arrangement.
- Is the material scaffolded appropriately?
Yes, the book combines a four main series about basic tonality, tonal practices on the intervals, rhythm and rhythmic practice on the intervals with specific small sections of related knowledge from simple to hard.
- What are the strengths and weaknesses of this materials?
The purpose of this book is helping people develops a sense of sophisticated tonal skill as a foundation to learn various sight-singing work which can be effective in some ways. Moreover, there are many specific explanations for music beginner to learn to prepare for sigh-read. However, the content is too long and complex and there are hard to find feasible exercise in a concise way.
- Are the materials based in real music or specially composed exercises?
No, the materials are mostly written by authors instead of officials.
- Do the materials feature a variety of rhythmic and melodic content?
Yes, there are huge numbers of small tonal exercises and rhythmic exercises for teachers to use.
* Overall, I think the Melodia:a comprehensive course in sight-singing, by Samuel Winkley Cole. can be the more feasible book for me to use because the arrangement of this book is more concise than my last two sight-singing book and the classical sources of this book are more abundant too.